Practice question
Compare how Hughes presents a soldier’s experience of a charge in Bayonet Charge and how Tennyson presents it in The Charge of the Light Brigade.
Guided comparison
Read questions 1–8 with their notes. When you reach questions 9 and 10, jot down a sentence of your own for each.
-
What brings these poems together?
Tennyson uses a driving rhythm and a collective viewpoint. Hughes follows one soldier’s stumbling movement and fear from the inside.
-
Whose experience do we follow?
Tennyson keeps returning to “the six hundred”, giving the riders a collective identity. Hughes opens with “he was running”, dropping us into one soldier’s experience.
-
How does the movement sound?
Tennyson’s “Half a league” beats out a steady forward movement. Hughes’s “Stumbling” breaks the impression of a smooth or controlled advance.
-
How much do the soldiers understand?
Tennyson states “Someone had blunder’d”, so the reader knows an order has gone wrong. Hughes asks “In what cold clockwork” the man was a part, suggesting a system he cannot make sense of.
-
How close do we get to fear?
Tennyson surrounds the group with cannon, showing the scale of what they face. Hughes describes sweat as “molten iron”, making heat and strain feel immediate.
-
What happens to familiar ideas about duty?
“Theirs but to do and die” gives the brigade’s duty a stark rhythm. Hughes lists “King, honour, human dignity, etcetera” as ideas the soldier drops in the scramble to survive.
-
What are we left thinking about?
Tennyson asks readers to “Honour the charge they made”. Hughes leaves the soldier running with “terror” driving him, keeping the reader inside the moment.
-
How can you turn the comparison into a plan?
Group your ideas around movement, the people we follow, and the poets’ attitudes to courage. For each point, pick a detail from both poems and say how it helps answer the question.
Think for yourself
-
What changes if you tell a charge through one person?
Pick a detail from each poem and decide what becomes easier to see when a poet follows an individual.
Hint
Compare the repeated number in Tennyson and a bodily detail in Hughes.
-
Can duty and fear exist together in these poems?
Use one piece of evidence from each poem to explain your view.
Hint
Look at what the riders keep doing and what Hughes’s soldier keeps doing.
Write your own answer
Aim for about 500 words in 45 minutes when you are ready for timed practice.
Start from the poem named in the question. Make each paragraph about one idea and discuss both poems in that paragraph. Use short quotations and explain what the poets’ choices help you notice. Include one of your own ideas from questions 9 and 10 if it helps answer the question.
Compare Bayonet Charge with the other 14 poems
Start with the exam question. Can you explain how both poems help answer it in one sentence, and think of a short quotation from each? A close link on one question may be a stretch on another.
- Ozymandias — What grand claims are worth under pressure. The king’s boast sounds hollow beside his ruins. The soldier’s ideals of honour and loyalty lose their force as he runs for his life.
- London — A soldier’s experience of power. Blake connects a soldier’s sigh with the palace. Hughes puts us close to a soldier whose national ideals fall away as he runs under fire.
- The Prelude (extract) — Fear changes how people move. Wordsworth’s boy rows away from the mountain with trembling strokes. Hughes’s soldier stumbles forward and finds his former ideals giving way to the need to survive.
- My Last Duchess — The individual under pressure. The Duke condemns the Duchess for behaviour he cannot control. Hughes brings us inside the fear of a soldier caught up in forces beyond his understanding.
- The Charge of the Light Brigade — What a charge feels like. Tennyson uses a driving rhythm and a collective viewpoint. Hughes follows one soldier’s stumbling movement and fear from the inside. See the guided comparison.
- Exposure — The physical experience of war. Owen concentrates on cold, waiting and exhaustion. Hughes concentrates on sudden movement, heat and panic under fire.
- Storm on the Island — How sound creates fear. Heaney uses battle language to make the storm sound like an attack. Hughes uses abrupt sounds and movement to put us close to a soldier under actual fire.
- Remains — Fear and the effects of combat. Hughes follows panic during a charge. Armitage follows a shooting and the fear and guilt that persist after the soldier returns home.
- Poppies — Where the poems place us in relation to war. Hughes puts us beside a soldier running under fire. Weir places us with a mother remembering a departure and imagining contact with her absent son.
- War Photographer — Different ways of witnessing danger. Hughes puts readers inside a soldier’s confused experience. Duffy puts readers beside someone who records others’ suffering and later sees his own memories develop with the photographs.
- Tissue — Ideas and the vulnerable body. Hughes shows patriotic ideals losing force as the soldier fights to survive. Dharker’s poem moves from borders and buildings to the vulnerability of skin.
- The Émigrée — When images or words can sustain you. The patriotism Hughes’s soldier once felt gives way to panic. Rumens’s speaker keeps her image of the city even when accounts of it are threatening.
- Checking Out Me History — Questioning what people have been taught. Hughes’s soldier loses his grasp on the ideals associated with going to war. Agard’s speaker actively questions a limited view of history and looks for his own sources of identity.
- Kamikaze — How duty gives way under pressure. Hughes makes self-preservation more urgent than patriotic ideals. Garland imagines a pilot drawn back by sea life and memories, then shows how his return is judged.