Practice question
Compare how Wordsworth presents the power of nature in The Prelude (extract) and how Heaney presents it in Storm on the Island.
Guided comparison
Read questions 1–8 with their notes. When you reach questions 9 and 10, jot down a sentence of your own for each.
-
What brings these poems together?
Wordsworth’s boy is shaken when a mountain seems to rise and follow him. Heaney’s islanders build for storms, yet the force of the wind still frightens them.
-
How confident do the speakers sound at first?
Wordsworth’s boy calls the outing “an act of stealth”, suggesting he feels bold enough to take the boat. Heaney opens with “We are prepared”, expressing a community’s practical confidence.
-
What makes each threat seem powerful?
Wordsworth repeats “huge” when the mountain appears. Heaney says the wind “dives / And strafes”, making the attack sound like one by aircraft.
-
How do the poets make nature seem alive?
The peak “Upreared its head”, as if it were a creature able to follow the boat. Heaney’s “spits like a tame cat / Turned savage” makes familiar sea spray suddenly seem hostile.
-
How do the speakers react physically?
Wordsworth’s boy rows with “trembling oars”. Heaney’s “We just sit tight” suggests waiting indoors as the storm does its worst.
-
What does the choice of pronoun do?
Wordsworth’s repeated “I” makes the memory personal. Heaney’s “we” draws attention to shared knowledge, preparations and fear.
-
How long does the fear last in each poem?
Wordsworth says the forms trouble his dreams “for many days”. Heaney ends with the present-tense “we fear”, leaving the fear in the community’s voice.
-
How can you turn the comparison into a plan?
Group your ideas around initial confidence, how nature seems to act, and what fear leaves behind. For each point, pick a detail from both poems and say how it helps answer the question.
Think for yourself
-
How does the shape of each threat affect the fear?
Explain how a threatening thing can be frightening whether you can see it or cannot.
Hint
Compare the clearly seen “huge peak” with the storm called a “huge nothing”.
-
Which opening best prepares you for its ending?
Choose a detail from each opening and explain what has changed by each ending.
Hint
Look at the boy’s pleasure in rowing and the islanders’ first confident statement.
Write your own answer
Aim for about 500 words in 45 minutes when you are ready for timed practice.
Start from the poem named in the question. Make each paragraph about one idea and discuss both poems in that paragraph. Use short quotations and explain what the poets’ choices help you notice. Include one of your own ideas from questions 9 and 10 if it helps answer the question.
Compare The Prelude (extract) with the other 14 poems
Start with the exam question. Can you explain how both poems help answer it in one sentence, and think of a short quotation from each? A close link on one question may be a stretch on another.
- Ozymandias — The scale of nature. The desert dwarfs what remains of Ozymandias’s monument. The looming mountain makes Wordsworth’s young boat-stealer lose his early confidence.
- London — Freedom and restraint. Blake’s walker hears suffering in regulated city streets. Wordsworth’s boy starts out feeling free on the lake and is checked by the sight of the mountain.
- My Last Duchess — What happens when control slips. Wordsworth’s boy loses his confidence when a mountain seems to pursue him. Browning’s Duke insists on controlling the portrait, yet his speech gives away more about him than he intends.
- The Charge of the Light Brigade — Movement and danger. Wordsworth’s lone rower moves from pleasure to fear. Tennyson’s repeated rhythm carries a group of riders into danger they have been ordered to face.
- Exposure — Nature’s power over people. Wordsworth turns one encounter with a mountain into a memory of fear. Owen presents wind and cold as threats that wear soldiers down through prolonged exposure.
- Storm on the Island — Nature can make people feel small. Wordsworth’s boy is shaken when a mountain seems to rise and follow him. Heaney’s islanders build for storms, yet the force of the wind still frightens them. See the guided comparison.
- Bayonet Charge — Fear changes how people move. Wordsworth’s boy rows away from the mountain with trembling strokes. Hughes’s soldier stumbles forward and finds his former ideals giving way to the need to survive.
- Remains — An experience that stays in the mind. The mountain changes the way the boy imagines the world after the boat trip. A shooting returns to trouble Armitage’s soldier after his tour has ended.
- Poppies — Revisiting a charged memory. Wordsworth’s adult speaker remembers a childhood encounter that changed him. Weir’s mother recalls gestures and images from the day her son left.
- War Photographer — The mind after a disturbing sight. Wordsworth’s boy continues to see huge forms in his mind. Duffy’s photographer sees an image develop and remembers the person and the grief behind it.
- Tissue — The scale of nature and human designs. Wordsworth puts a small boat beside a mountain that seems enormous. Dharker imagines light passing through maps and the paper plans from which buildings begin.
- The Émigrée — Landscape as a memory. Wordsworth’s remembered landscape becomes troubling after one night on the lake. Rumens’s speaker holds on to the sunshine of a city she knew as a child.
- Checking Out Me History — An experience that shapes identity. Wordsworth looks back on a moment that altered his imagination. Agard’s speaker seeks out histories that help him shape his sense of who he is.
- Kamikaze — An encounter with nature changes a journey. Wordsworth’s boy turns the boat around after seeing the mountain. Garland’s pilot turns back after a flight during which sea life and fishing boats fill the daughter’s imagined account.