Practice question
Compare how Garland presents the effects of conflict on families in Kamikaze and how Weir presents it in Poppies.
Guided comparison
Read questions 1–8 with their notes. When you reach questions 9 and 10, jot down a sentence of your own for each.
-
What brings these poems together?
Weir follows a mother whose affection for her absent son remains. Garland follows a family whose attachment is distorted by expectations of sacrifice.
-
Who tells each family story?
Weir gives the mother the direct voice of “I”. Garland begins with the pilot’s departure and later lets his daughter tell the story from her position in the family.
-
How do ordinary objects make war personal?
Weir’s “blazer” gives the mother something she can touch before her son leaves. Garland’s “little fishing boats” connect the flight to the pilot’s life and memories on the coast.
-
How does each poem use a child’s earlier life?
Weir’s speaker remembers the “Eskimos” game, a detail of childhood affection that comes back to her as her son is leaving. Garland pictures the pilot as a boy beside the sea, recalling a world that existed before the mission.
-
Where do feelings go unspoken?
Weir’s mother says she was “brave” as she let him go, suggesting feelings she held back. Garland says “we too learned / to be silent”, showing how silence becomes a family habit.
-
What part does the wider community play?
Weir places private grief beside the public “war memorial”. Garland shows a household responding to communal expectations of sacrifice by treating a surviving man as absent.
-
What is the effect of each ending?
Weir’s mother listens for a “playground voice”, holding on to a memory of the son as a child. Garland asks which may have been “the better way to die”, turning survival into a painful question.
-
How can you turn the comparison into a plan?
Group your ideas around family voices, memories and the final images. For each point, pick a detail from both poems and say how it helps answer the question.
Think for yourself
-
How do the poems make an absent person feel present?
Pick a remembered detail from each poem and explain what it gives us of the person’s life.
Hint
Think about childhood and the sound or sight associated with it.
-
Which silence is more painful to read about?
Choose an example from each poem and explain what causes the silence and whom it hurts.
Hint
Compare the mother straining to hear with the children learning to keep silent.
Write your own answer
Aim for about 500 words in 45 minutes when you are ready for timed practice.
Start from the poem named in the question. Make each paragraph about one idea and discuss both poems in that paragraph. Use short quotations and explain what the poets’ choices help you notice. Include one of your own ideas from questions 9 and 10 if it helps answer the question.
Compare Kamikaze with the other 14 poems
Start with the exam question. Can you explain how both poems help answer it in one sentence, and think of a short quotation from each? A close link on one question may be a stretch on another.
- Ozymandias — Who controls a person’s reputation? The ruined statue makes the king’s boast look hollow. Garland shows a pilot’s family and community treating him as if he were dead after his decision to return.
- London — Pressure to conform. Blake presents social restraints as something people carry in their minds. Garland shows a pilot’s family learning to silence and ignore him after his return.
- The Prelude (extract) — An encounter with nature changes a journey. Wordsworth’s boy turns the boat around after seeing the mountain. Garland’s pilot turns back after a flight during which sea life and fishing boats fill the daughter’s imagined account.
- My Last Duchess — Judging people who fall short of expectations. The Duke condemns his wife for failing to favour him above others. Garland’s pilot is shunned for returning from a mission he was expected to die on.
- The Charge of the Light Brigade — Duty and its human costs. Tennyson honours soldiers who obey orders despite a mistake. Garland considers the cost to a pilot and his family when he turns back.
- Exposure — War and exclusion from home. Owen’s soldiers imagine being shut out from home. Garland’s pilot reaches home and is then shut out of family and community life.
- Storm on the Island — An island setting experienced in different ways. Heaney presents an island community at the mercy of the sea and wind. Garland’s imagined flight takes in a coastal world of boats, fish and family memory.
- Bayonet Charge — How duty gives way under pressure. Hughes makes self-preservation more urgent than patriotic ideals. Garland imagines a pilot drawn back by sea life and memories, then shows how his return is judged.
- Remains — War’s aftermath within the family and community. Armitage’s soldier returns and carries a memory he cannot escape. Garland’s pilot returns and is excluded by others for surviving.
- Poppies — What war does to families. Weir follows a mother whose affection for her absent son remains. Garland follows a family whose attachment is distorted by expectations of sacrifice. See the guided comparison.
- War Photographer — Telling the story of an absent person. Duffy’s photographer preserves an image that brings back his memory of a grieving woman. Garland’s daughter tries to imagine a decision her father scarcely spoke about.
- Tissue — Human life and imposed systems. Dharker imagines putting human life ahead of fixed plans and boundaries. Garland shows what happens when a pilot survives a mission his community expected him to die on.
- The Émigrée — What it means to be treated as an outsider. Rumens’s speaker keeps her attachment to a city despite accusations against her. Garland’s pilot returns to his own community and finds himself excluded.
- Checking Out Me History — Whose story is allowed to be told? Agard’s speaker brings hidden histories into his own account. Garland’s daughter reconstructs the story of a man whom his family learned to ignore.