Practice question
Compare how Tennyson presents a soldier’s experience of a charge in The Charge of the Light Brigade and how Hughes presents it in Bayonet Charge.
Guided comparison
Read questions 1–8 with their notes. When you reach questions 9 and 10, jot down a sentence of your own for each.
-
What brings these poems together?
Tennyson uses a driving rhythm and a collective viewpoint. Hughes follows one soldier’s stumbling movement and fear from the inside.
-
Whose experience do we follow?
Tennyson keeps returning to “the six hundred”, giving the riders a collective identity. Hughes opens with “he was running”, dropping us into one soldier’s experience.
-
How does the movement sound?
Tennyson’s “Half a league” beats out a steady forward movement. Hughes’s “Stumbling” breaks the impression of a smooth or controlled advance.
-
How much do the soldiers understand?
Tennyson states “Someone had blunder’d”, so the reader knows an order has gone wrong. Hughes asks “In what cold clockwork” the man was a part, suggesting a system he cannot make sense of.
-
How close do we get to fear?
Tennyson surrounds the group with cannon, showing the scale of what they face. Hughes describes sweat as “molten iron”, making heat and strain feel immediate.
-
What happens to familiar ideas about duty?
“Theirs but to do and die” gives the brigade’s duty a stark rhythm. Hughes lists “King, honour, human dignity, etcetera” as ideas the soldier drops in the scramble to survive.
-
What are we left thinking about?
Tennyson asks readers to “Honour the charge they made”. Hughes leaves the soldier running with “terror” driving him, keeping the reader inside the moment.
-
How can you turn the comparison into a plan?
Group your ideas around movement, the people we follow, and the poets’ attitudes to courage. For each point, pick a detail from both poems and say how it helps answer the question.
Think for yourself
-
What changes if you tell a charge through one person?
Pick a detail from each poem and decide what becomes easier to see when a poet follows an individual.
Hint
Compare the repeated number in Tennyson and a bodily detail in Hughes.
-
Can duty and fear exist together in these poems?
Use one piece of evidence from each poem to explain your view.
Hint
Look at what the riders keep doing and what Hughes’s soldier keeps doing.
Write your own answer
Aim for about 500 words in 45 minutes when you are ready for timed practice.
Start from the poem named in the question. Make each paragraph about one idea and discuss both poems in that paragraph. Use short quotations and explain what the poets’ choices help you notice. Include one of your own ideas from questions 9 and 10 if it helps answer the question.
Compare The Charge of the Light Brigade with the other 14 poems
Start with the exam question. Can you explain how both poems help answer it in one sentence, and think of a short quotation from each? A close link on one question may be a stretch on another.
- Ozymandias — Who deserves to be remembered? Shelley undercuts a king’s demand that others admire him. Tennyson urges readers to honour soldiers who rode into danger after someone in command blundered.
- London — Authority and its costs. Blake links the soldier’s sigh to palace walls. Tennyson honours soldiers who obey an order that someone in authority got wrong.
- The Prelude (extract) — Movement and danger. Wordsworth’s lone rower moves from pleasure to fear. Tennyson’s repeated rhythm carries a group of riders into danger they have been ordered to face.
- My Last Duchess — Orders and who bears the consequences. Browning’s Duke hints at a fatal outcome of his own orders. Tennyson shows soldiers dying after a command goes wrong, while honouring their courage.
- Exposure — Two pictures of soldiers’ courage. Tennyson celebrates a cavalry charge under fire. Owen follows soldiers enduring cold and inactivity, with little sense that their suffering will be recognised.
- Storm on the Island — Groups facing danger. Tennyson’s riders obey a command and move towards gunfire. Heaney’s islanders prepare together for a wind described in the language of attack.
- Bayonet Charge — What a charge feels like. Tennyson uses a driving rhythm and a collective viewpoint. Hughes follows one soldier’s stumbling movement and fear from the inside. See the guided comparison.
- Remains — How soldiers are remembered. Tennyson asks the public to honour the brigade. Armitage lets us hear a soldier privately reliving a killing for which he feels responsible.
- Poppies — Public honour and family grief. Tennyson praises the courage of a whole brigade. Weir uses remembrance imagery to tell the private story of a mother whose son has left.
- War Photographer — How the public sees war. Tennyson directly calls on readers to remember the brigade. Duffy shows readers briefly moved by photographs before turning back to their own lives.
- Tissue — How human lives are counted. The repeated number of riders in Tennyson makes the brigade memorable as a group. Dharker starts with paper records of individual births and deaths and ends by thinking about human skin.
- The Émigrée — How a speaker keeps a memory alive. Tennyson demands public remembrance of the brigade. Rumens’s speaker preserves a personal memory of her city despite what others tell her about it.
- Checking Out Me History — Who gets a place in public memory? Tennyson asks readers to honour the brigade. Agard asks why some historical figures are celebrated in education while others were kept from him.
- Kamikaze — Duty and its human costs. Tennyson honours soldiers who obey orders despite a mistake. Garland considers the cost to a pilot and his family when he turns back.