Practice question
Compare how Rumens presents how speakers use images of troubled places in The Émigrée and how Duffy presents it in War Photographer.
Guided comparison
Read questions 1–8 with their notes. When you reach questions 9 and 10, jot down a sentence of your own for each.
-
What brings these poems together?
Duffy’s photographer records suffering that distant readers see briefly. Rumens’s speaker keeps a bright personal picture of a city that others describe in darker terms.
-
Who carries each image?
Duffy’s photographer works alone with “spools of suffering”. Rumens’s speaker holds her own remembered city through “an impression of sunlight”.
-
What does light do in each poem?
Duffy gives the darkroom a red glow that helps create a solemn mood. Rumens repeats sunlight to make the city’s brightness persist through bad news about it.
-
How does each image reach us?
Duffy describes a face beginning to appear as a print develops. Rumens’s city reaches us through a childhood memory, with details such as its streets and the language she carried away.
-
What does distance do to the observer?
Duffy contrasts “Rural England” with the places where the images were taken. Rumens’s speaker is separated from her city but says it “lies down in front of me”, giving memory a physical presence.
-
How do other people respond?
Duffy’s newspaper readers may briefly shed tears before returning to their routines. Rumens’s “They accuse me” suggests hostile voices trying to change the speaker’s relation to her city.
-
How do the endings affect the image?
Duffy’s “they do not care” expresses bitterness about the audience. Rumens ends with a shadow that is “evidence of sunlight”, making even darkness point to what the speaker values.
-
How can you turn the comparison into a plan?
Group your ideas around who sees the images, light and darkness, and the endings. For each point, pick a detail from both poems and say how it helps answer the question.
Think for yourself
-
What can an image leave out?
Choose a detail from each poem and explain what a photograph or a memory might show only partly.
Hint
Consider the reader who sees a selected picture and the speaker who remembers childhood sunlight.
-
Which image seems to have the longer effect on its audience?
Say whose response you are comparing, then use a detail from each poem.
Hint
You might compare the newspaper readers and Rumens’s speaker.
Write your own answer
Aim for about 500 words in 45 minutes when you are ready for timed practice.
Start from the poem named in the question. Make each paragraph about one idea and discuss both poems in that paragraph. Use short quotations and explain what the poets’ choices help you notice. Include one of your own ideas from questions 9 and 10 if it helps answer the question.
Compare The Émigrée with the other 14 poems
Start with the exam question. Can you explain how both poems help answer it in one sentence, and think of a short quotation from each? A close link on one question may be a stretch on another.
- Ozymandias — What survives of a place. The desert surrounds the surviving fragments of the king’s world. Rumens’s speaker keeps a bright memory of her city despite disturbing reports about it.
- London — Two ways of remembering a city. Blake’s city is marked by suffering on almost every street. Rumens’s speaker holds on to a bright image of her city even when troubling news reaches her.
- The Prelude (extract) — Landscape as a memory. Wordsworth’s remembered landscape becomes troubling after one night on the lake. Rumens’s speaker holds on to the sunshine of a city she knew as a child.
- My Last Duchess — A voice claiming a place or a person. The Duke repeatedly presents the Duchess as his possession. Rumens’s speaker calls the city hers as an expression of attachment even when it seems to reject her.
- The Charge of the Light Brigade — How a speaker keeps a memory alive. Tennyson demands public remembrance of the brigade. Rumens’s speaker preserves a personal memory of her city despite what others tell her about it.
- Exposure — Belonging when home is beyond reach. Owen’s soldiers imagine a warm home and then find its doors closed to them. Rumens’s speaker carries a bright image of a city she cannot simply return to.
- Storm on the Island — How speakers describe a place under threat. Heaney links his community to a place constantly exposed to storms. Rumens’s displaced speaker insists on her attachment to a city under pressure.
- Bayonet Charge — When images or words can sustain you. The patriotism Hughes’s soldier once felt gives way to panic. Rumens’s speaker keeps her image of the city even when accounts of it are threatening.
- Remains — An image that returns unbidden. Armitage’s soldier is haunted by an image he wants to escape. Rumens’s speaker is haunted by sunlight and holds on to what it connects her to.
- Poppies — Holding on to someone or somewhere absent. Weir’s mother returns in memory to a son she can no longer reach. Rumens’s speaker keeps her city alive through images of childhood and sunlight.
- War Photographer — What an image of a place can convey. Duffy’s photographer records suffering that distant readers see briefly. Rumens’s speaker keeps a bright personal picture of a city that others describe in darker terms. See the guided comparison.
- Tissue — The power of borders and the limits of maps. Dharker imagines light passing through the lines that divide land. Rumens’s speaker keeps a personal connection with her city across political barriers.
- Checking Out Me History — Who can define your identity? Rumens’s speaker holds on to a city from which she is separated. Agard’s speaker resists a partial history and finds figures through whom he can make sense of his identity.
- Kamikaze — What it means to be treated as an outsider. Rumens’s speaker keeps her attachment to a city despite accusations against her. Garland’s pilot returns to his own community and finds himself excluded.